A new couple decide to go on a double date. They met via the Jewish dating app, J-date. They both bring their friends who have just recently got out of long term relationships. None of them are looking for something serious, but things get serious despite their best efforts. 

Joshua Salzman and Ryan Cunningham have written a very funny and charming musical about looking for love in NYC. The songs are fantastic and similar in style to the music in Rent. Instead of being all singing, there is a great amount of dialog which set up the songs nicely.  

Troy Dailey is great as the nerdy guy who struggles to get over his ex. Colin Huerta is so funny as his brother who teaches him that the best way to win her back is to not care. Cassandra Caruso is so good as the gal getting out of relationship and just looking for a fun rebound. Lauren Josephs is solid as her best friend, who does her best to stay in the friends with benefits zone. Renee Cohen and Ellie Rodriguez are excellent as the bartenders who clearly see what is going on among the couples. 

Cost of a ticket: $42

PlaylistHQ Economic Rating: Worth It +

Rating Scale: Exceptional Value > Worth It > Discounted > Go for Free > Don’t Bother

Get tickets now for I Love You Because through March 16th! 

Quinn Delaney